[ home ]    [ vita ]    [ teaching ]    [ research ]    [ links ]    [ personal ]

 

 

Primary fields: Industrial Organization and Applied Microeconomics

Dissertation: Consumer Search, Price Dispersion and Asymmetric Pricing

Working papers:
Rockets and Feathers. Understanding Asymmetric Pricing  RAND Journal of Economics, Vol. 40, No. 4, 2009.
Abstract: Prices rise like rockets but fall like feathers. This stylized fact of most markets was confirmed by many empirical studies in the past. However, the advance on theoretical work trying to explain it has been rather low. I present a simple model of competitive firms and rational partially-informed consumers where the asymmetric response to costs by firms emerges naturally. In contrast to public opinion and past work, collusion is not needed for such a result.

read an informal reference here

Consumer Search and Dynamic Price Dispersion: An Application to Gasoline Markets (joint with Ambarish Chandra)
Supplementary notes
Abstract: This paper studies the importance of imperfect information in explaining market price dispersion. We describe a theoretical model of endogenous non-sequential consumer search and then test its predictions using a new panel dataset on the U.S. retail gasoline industry.
We establish the importance of consumer search in this market using a simple and unique test of temporal price dispersion. We find that the number of price-rank changes among pairs of gas stations located at the same street intersection, where consumer search is absent, is significantly lower than the price-rank changes among stations located just out of sight of each other. Our empirical results regarding market price dispersion and firm's markup behavior are consistent with the predictions of the theoretical model of search. In particular, price dispersion and markups are positively related to the number of firms in the market and to consumers' search costs. Additionally, higher production costs lead to lower markups and price dispersion which in turn should reduce consumers' incentive to search. Therefore, increased search during periods of peak pricing is sub-optimal.

A Theory of Automatic Markdowns (coming soon!)
Abstract: This paper looks at the use of time-decreasing price schedules (automatic markdowns) as an alternative to fixed posted prices in environments where a seller is uncertain about consumers' valuations and their arrivals. We characterize the symmetric equilibrium under automatic markdowns as a function of consumers' transaction cost. In addition, we show the conditions under which a retailer prefers this method over the traditional fixed posted price.

 

Work in Progress:

Location and Competition. The Retail Gasoline Market
Retail prices in the gasoline market differ significantly across locations within a city or geographical region and that has been the cause of heated public debates on the degree of competition in the market. This price dispersion is a consequence of gasoline not being a homogeneous good. Rather it is a differentiated product, giving firms some market power. In this paper I use a unique dataset that covers the population of gasoline stations in the market to measure the effect of spatial differentiation on retail prices and market power. This allows for counterfactual experiments designed to measure the welfare effects of horizontal mergers, divestitures requirements and zoning restrictions imposed by city governments.
The model to be estimated is a nested discrete choice model in which consumers first choose the type of gasoline (regular, midgrade, premium or diesel) to purchase and then the station to buy from. On the supply side, stations simultaneously choose prices according to their contracts with the refineries. This pricing game is the last of a two-stage game where location and product characteristics are chosen first.
The supply equilibrium conditions together with the aggregate demands faced by the stations allow the estimation of demand and cost parameters by GMM. No quantities or market shares are used in the estimation (see Thomadsen, 2002) avoiding the problem of measurement error that is always present in gasoline datasets (Manuszak 2001, Hastings 2001).

Races, Optimal Prizes and Soccer
In this paper, a model of soccer games is used to understand optimal prize schemes for dynamic competitions with a known ending period. In soccer games, teams act strategically at every moment of the game by deciding effort levels based on the teams' characteristics. We study the effects of the reward system on those decisions. In particular, what are the consequences of changing the system from 2 points per win (2-1-0) to a system of 3 points per win (3-1-0)? Are there better schemes that make teams exert more effort?
This framework of dynamic competition is not exclusive to soccer and can be use to analyze various –and probably more relevant- situations. Primary and general presidential elections, innovation races and government contests are some examples. Formal models of this type of races have been also studied in the past (AOKI 1991). The feature of general models is that optimal reward systems are sensitive to the assumptions on transition probabilities as well as agents’ objective functions. As a result, few general characterizations can be made. In that sense, soccer games present an excellent opportunity to push the analysis a step further by using available data to estimate the parameters of a fairly flexible structural model. Unlike reduced form estimations (Palomino et. al. 2002), the estimations obtained in this paper allow for the evaluation of different reward schemes. [with Juan Pantano]

Vertical Integration or Separation? Contract Choices by Gasoline Refineries

Past Work:

“The Use of Derivatives by Non-Financial Argentinean Firms” with Gustavo Jaconiuk and Eduardo Levy Yeyati. CIF Working Paper # 7 (September 2000). In Spanish.

“Local Government's Debt. The case of the Municipalities in Buenos Aires” with Agustin Lodola, 30th Public Finance Annual Meetings, Cordoba Argentina 1997. In Spanish.

top

 

 

[last update: Nov 2009]